William Pfaff is the author of The Irony of Manifest Destiny, published in June 2010 by Walker and Company (New York) -- his tenth and culminating work on international politics and the American destiny. He describes the neglected sources and unforeseen consequences of the tragedy towards which the nation's current effort to remake the world to fit America's measure is leading. His previous books and his articles in The New York Review of Books, The New Yorker, and his syndicated newspaper column, featured for a quarter century in the globally read International Herald Tribune, have made him one of America's most respected and internationally influential interpreters of world affairs.   [Read more...]
Columns : The American Top Secret Kept from Americans
on 2013/7/24 15:00:00 (3373 reads)

Paris, July 24, 2013 – For some twenty years, in another and more youthful phase of my life, I was one of the (apparently) several hundred thousand Americans who possessed a Top Secret security classification.

This was assigned to me I know not why, as I was a Korean War non-commissioned officer, my sole military qualification that of “small-unit infantry leader,” on my way to the Far East Command. You may imagine how many secrets I knew! Some kind of foul-up further up the line I supposed.

With military service during the Korean war, an active Army Reserve commitment, a period of involvement in cold war political warfare undertakings meant to provide western intellectual and cultural publications, European and American sculpture and painting, plus dissident Marxist writings to readers inside the Soviet bloc and in the Middle East and Asia, and then an encounter with a think-tank dealing with international relations and strategy (and with why the Vietnam War would end in disaster), the TS clearance went on and on.

It was not a card in my wallet, or a subscription to be renewed, nor did it weigh on my mind. I kept it even after a Soviet KGB man at the UN struck up a conversation with me at a party in New York City, and two sober-miened (and obviously well-informed) FBI agents subsequently invited me out for a coffee and asked if I wouldn’t like to follow up the acquaintance on their behalf. I said that if the Russian called me I would let them know. But I wouldn’t pursue him in order to set him up, which is what they had in mind. They seemed to find this a reasonable moral distinction to draw, thanked me and paid for the coffee.

When I left the hushed halls of secrecy for free-lance writing, nobody wrote to expel me from the “cleared” world. For all I know, even now, three American wars and six American presidencies further on, including the Barack Obama administration, for which I voted (now operating its pitiless inquisition into whistle-blowers, with life-imprisonment for them all -- “Off with their Heads!”), I may still be possessor of a TS clearance. Some kind of foul-up further up the line.

Now the reason I am writing all of this, at the risk of naked lifetime incarceration in a Marine Corps brig or a Moscow airport men’s room, is that never in my life have I known a Top Secret.

Even the non-top secrets I have ever known were secret only because the U.S. Government would have been politically embarrassed were they known to the American public or to Congress. They were already long known to the Soviet Union and the Warsaw Pact bloc, who were America’s then-enemies.

Take the operation for sending dissident Marxist literature and avant-garde American and European art and literature to the Soviet bloc. The people who received this material in the mail or had it distributed to them by other means were not such fools as not to know – and be grateful -- that western agencies were sending it.

The people from whom the operation was kept secret were Congress and the American public. Why? Because they might be (and some powerful individuals certainly would have been!) outraged that Marxist writings, dissident or otherwise, and “decadent,” abstract, or avant-garde western art, was being distributed abroad by the American government at taxpayer expense.

The same was true of the secret that during the cold war the CIA sponsored the activities, conferences and magazines of the liberal-internationalist and anti-Comintern Congress for Cultural Freedom. This fact is even today cited with outrage not only by right-wing figures and reactionary senators in America, but by most of the western liberal-intellectual community. The reputations of the poet Stephen Spender, the New York intellectuals Irving Kristol and Melvin Lasky (the latter founder and inspiration of the Congress’s Encounter magazine) were permanently tainted by their creation of probably the most important and influential international intellectual magazine of the 1953-1991 period.

The principal “outrage” for which Bradley Manning is today imprisoned is the video he revealed to the online world of an American helicopter in Irak pitilessly shooting up a group of civilians, including would-be rescuers and children. To whom was this video a revelation? Not, surely, the Iraqis who were victims of this barbarous act, and had seen it often replicated. It was being kept a secret from the American public.

What crime is Edward Snowden accused of committing? Not his revelation of American global eavesdropping on foreign governments, which every major government in the world already knew of, or took for granted as existing. Snowden is an international political fugitive because he revealed to the American people what their own government was doing.

Big Brother exists! – but he is an American. This is the big secret which the Obama administration spends billions of dollars and enlists millions of individuals to conceal from the very people who are paying for it all. If, or when, this is grasped, Americans will truly have a right to be horrified – assuming it is not too late.

© Copyright 2013 by Tribune Content Agency. All Rights Reserved.


For rights to publish the above article To print this article To e-mail this article To print this article (PDF format)
His books