William Pfaff is the author of The Irony of Manifest Destiny, published in June 2010 by Walker and Company (New York) -- his tenth and culminating work on international politics and the American destiny. He describes the neglected sources and unforeseen consequences of the tragedy towards which the nation's current effort to remake the world to fit America's measure is leading. His previous books and his articles in The New York Review of Books, The New Yorker, and his syndicated newspaper column, featured for a quarter century in the globally read International Herald Tribune, have made him one of America's most respected and internationally influential interpreters of world affairs.   [Read more...]
Columns : Murder & Mystery in China
on 2012/4/18 18:08:31 (9794 reads)

Paris, April 17, 2012 - Events suggest that the long-overdue crisis
of China's Communist Party has arrived. Evidence is provided by the
affair of the Chinese police chief who tried to defect to the United
States and was turned away, the sensational murder of the mysterious
Englishman, about whom Britain's foreign secretary seems to have
known more than he told us at the time of the murder, and more than
he should have known, had the mysterious Englishman been merely the
innocuous expatriate he purported to be, and the British government
had claimed that he was.

China's crisis, as I have argued in the past, is that of political legitimacy. The legitimacy of the Chinese Communist
Party rests entirely on the fact that it has no political rival. It
inherited an abused and demoralized China from Mao Tse-tung in 1976,
after Mao's morbid narcissism, produced by absolute power, had
spurred him to launch the Great Leap Forward. Then came the Cultural
Revolution, culminating in the attempted coup of the "Gang of Four,"
empowered by his widow.

All this makes a history that cannot be dismissed. It remains relevant because it is recent - the treacherous false freedom of allowing "a hundred flowers bloom" began in 1956, and ended twenty years later, when Deng Xiaoping assumed power.

The actuality of this history demonstrates what could again happen. The Tiananmen Square demonstrations, and massacre, occurred in 1989, and the martial law
then imposed was ended in January 1990, just twenty-two years ago -
two years before Bill Clinton became president, while Margaret
Thatcher was still prime minister of Britain, and François Mitterrand
the president of France. Why, it was only yesterday!

In his book of essays and poems, No Enemies, No Hatred, the political dissident and Nobel Peace Prize laureate (2010) Liu Xiaobo has described the system that still governs China today, as it did under Mao Tse-tung. “In order to guard the power of its one-party dictatorship and the vested interests of the privileged elite, the Party keeps a tight grip on the appointments and dismissals of officials at every level. In effect it takes this power out of the hands of the people, where rightly it belongs, and turns it into an item of private exchange within the Party. The power of every official at every level comes not from below, from the people, but from above, from higher levels within the structure of private authority. This fact then establishes a pattern: the first priority of officials is always to serve the higher-ups (because, in effect, this serves oneself)….”

The mechanism for determining supreme power is the Party Congress, held every decade, which will take place this fall, “a comet-like event that awes onlookers as a portent of change and renewal,” as the writer Ian Johnson has described it, the most spectacular of which portent – thus far, this year – being the fall from power of Bo Xilai, a prominent regional official and member of the Politburo, widely considered a candidate for the Politburo’s Standing Committee, an appointment considered a crucial step towards the highest office, which many thought was Mr. Bo’s destiny.

Now he has not only been disgraced and stripped of office, but his wife is being held on suspicion of involvement in the murder of a former family friend, Neil Heywood, a longtime resident of China.

It is rumored that the illegal transfer abroad of large sums of money was involved in the affair, but mere money seems too insignificant to explain the rank of the people involved and the now-unsuccessful efforts of the British government to distance itself from the matter, Mr. Heywood being said to have once been a member of the British Secret Intelligence Service.

All very intriguing for we Foreign Devils following the affair in the sensationalist western press, although not at all so for the Bo family, including their son at Harvard, whose flamboyant displays of wealth and privilege while a student in Britain and the United States seem to have become well known among the Facebook-linked children of the Chinese ruling elite, and to security authorities as well.

On Monday, China’s Prime Minister Wen Jiabao again warned his government it must end a culture of corruption lest this lead to the end of Communist rule. The warning is eminently justified with respect to a ruling body which has itself done little to deserve power, other than by being descended from the individuals who in the early and mid-twentieth century carried out the Communist revolution.

Not only is China experiencing grave scandals involving officials across the country, but foreign residents report a culture of graft at all levels of society. The country’s long history is distinguished by xenophobic, nationalist, separatist, and peasant and workers’ revolts. The dynastic system collapsed in ruin in 1911, and since then China has seen not only Sun Yet-sen’s, Chiang Kai-shek’s, and Mao Tse-tung’s nationalist and ideological movements and civil wars, but persisting sectoral revolts and warlordism, foreign invasion, and extensive civil unrest.

China is a turbulent society, and foreigners are mistaken to take its recent economic success as a guarantee of political order, as most seem to do.

© Copyright 2012 by Tribune Media Services International. All Rights Reserved.


For rights to publish the above article To print this article To e-mail this article To print this article (PDF format)
His books